Wondering what the average success rate on the "recycled" troll weapons is.
I am trying to get my warrior set up with a pair of the Vengeful Honed blades of the Ykesha. On our first try, out of 5 attempts, the troll smith got 1 success. He actually told me that it was the first time out of many attemrts that he had EVER made one.
This is with 215 skill, + the 15% hammer.
Not surprised to get one out of five. Rather pleased, in fact. I was surprised to find that he considered a 20% rate one of his GOOD runs on these. Does anyone do these on a regular basis? If so, what kind of success are you having?
Oh, and BTW, while the sword has a recommended level of 45, it procs for my 43 warrior.
I am trying to get my warrior set up with a pair of the Vengeful Honed blades of the Ykesha. On our first try, out of 5 attempts, the troll smith got 1 success. He actually told me that it was the first time out of many attemrts that he had EVER made one.
This is with 215 skill, + the 15% hammer.
Not surprised to get one out of five. Rather pleased, in fact. I was surprised to find that he considered a 20% rate one of his GOOD runs on these. Does anyone do these on a regular basis? If so, what kind of success are you having?
Oh, and BTW, while the sword has a recommended level of 45, it procs for my 43 warrior.


He is smithing with a skill of 252, so he has the best possible chance for success. Now I'm sure I was very fortunate, but I've heard many people complaining about their success rate on these and I just don't think it is consitent with what I've seen in my experience with them. That same smith later made a couple more for another guildmate of mine after seeing how happy I was with them, and he failed something like two or three times before making him his two Yaks. Looks like a combine best attempted at maximum skill to minimize failures.
Comment