Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Rarity of *SOME* tradeskill trophy items

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Rarity of *SOME* tradeskill trophy items

    While this may get moved to baking (due to the specific examples) or Primal Scream (due solely to vented frustration).... Here goes:

    I will try to not use the word "equal" here, but if I somehow slip up, please replace equal with one of the following: consistent, fair, average.

    I have spent several years (as well as numerous others) playing EQ. While I have been a member of a raiding guild, an Alliance of guilds with a focus on raiding, a small family guild, and currently, the remains of a tradeskill guild, I still play EQ because it is a diverse experience game in which I can choose to tradeskill, merchant (barter in bazaar), hunt in a small group, or go after the "big game" in a raid. I have the OPPORTUNITY to choose what I want to do in the game.

    I have completed the series of tradeskill trophies on several characters: 55 shaman, (tradeskills range from 65 to 190, all trophies possible), 69 ranger (tradeskill range from 150 to 230, 4 trophies, working on the rest), 60 enchanter (tradeskill range from 200 to 254, 5 trophies, working on the rest).

    I have found a stark disparity in the difficulty of the various trophies. Specifically the Baking trophy. The requirement for NEST DRAKE MEAT is a bit ridiculous.

    I have had a buyer up in the bazaar for 3 weeks offering as high as 1k plat for NEST DRAKE MEAT. I have spent 3 weeks in a combination of regular and instanced versions of Lavaspinners, suffered numerous deaths to gating mobs that you can't stun (at least not with a 60 cleric, 60 ranger and 60 enchanter), and have not seen a single meat drop.

    I have even used my 70 ranger, cleric, druid combo to clean house in regular lavaspinners for three nights (that's 3 hours a night).

    I haven't camped this much for ONE item since my ranger was in the mid 40s and I was looking for a FBSS in Lower Guk.

    From my searches on EQ Traders, it seems the NEST DRAKE MEAT is used in 88 recipes. Should the developers have spent that much time to develop 88 recipes of stat foods, plus the "tuning" of the trophy quest, plus the beta test time, loot drop tuning time, etc... for a drop that appears to be on the same table as the Manastone?

    I realize that some of the "harder" instanced zones may have a higher drop rate, but, seriously, it should have dropped by now. My ranger has TWO STACKS of drake intestines and not a single meat.

    If the developers are so intent on tying the tradeskill items to the "appropriate" character level, then why are the tradeskills not limited to X skill points per exp level as 1HS, meditate, abjuration, etc.?

    I guess that I'm just really frustrated that I try to obtain the quest items I need with the character that I'm going to use them.

    Being level 80 with a gazillion AAs, GLAs, RLAs, and all the 'best' raid gear in the game it not THE ultimate part of the game. It may be YOUR ultimate part, but it is not MY ultimate part.

    Someone really needs to look at the drop rate in the "lower" level zones.

    Tonight, I think I will actually count the various drakes I kill and keep track of their loot for a better sample of the frustration, but that may be more 'work' than I'm willing to do for a game.

    Mon
    Mondrivun
    Enchanter of 7th Cavalry
    Bristlebane

    Being level 80 with a gazillion AAs, Group Leadership Abilities, and Raid Leadership abilities is not THE ultimate part of the game. It may be YOUR ultimate part of the game, but it is not MY ultimate part.

  • #2
    I have only seen that meat drop in Nest myself, though i havent spent a whole lot of time in lavaspinners.
    Xcoz of Sapientia

    Comment


    • #3
      Sounds like a bad RNG on the loots or targeted too low mob levels, I often saw 1 nest drake meat every other Creator mission back when it was still the best XP grind. That's 1 meat per group per hour on the average.

      Baking trophy quest could be retuned to use something a bit more common than nest drake meat.

      Grolyn Blacknife
      Beastlord
       T:7
       M:0
       T:6
       M:1
       T:6
       M:0
      Fletching:
      284
       T:7
       M:0
       T:6
       M:0
       T:7
       M:2
      Zira Blacknife
      Shaman
       T:7
       M:0
      Maelin Starpyre
      Vazaelle
      Reiseraa
      Necro
      Research:
      102

      Comment


      • #4
        Keeping track...

        So, I took my three box crew into a DoN mission tonight, Grounding the Drakes, to see what would drop.

        Delve Drake - dropped Claw and Frothing Drake Blood
        Delve Drake - dropped Frothing Drake Blood
        Delve Evoker - dropped Guven and Mondrivun after gating and bringing a train
        Delve Evoker - dropped Grubby Fine Papyrus, Drake Fang
        Delve Evoker (wanderer) - Drake Wing, Drake Fang
        Delve Diviner - dropped Drake Wing, Cryptanthus, Frothing Drake Blood
        Delve Drake - dropped Frothing Drake Blood
        Delve Diviner - dropped Silkworm Larva
        Delve Drake - dropping nothing
        Delve Drake - dropped nothing
        Delve Drake - dropped Frothing Drake Blood and Drake Fang
        Delve Drake - dropped Frothing Drake Blood and Drake Fang
        Delve Drake - dropped Frothing Drake Blood
        Delve Spellbinder - dropped Frothing Drake Blood, Drake Claw
        Delve Drake - dropped periodot
        Delve Spellbinder - dropped Frothing Drake Blood, Drake Claw Drake Spikes
        Delve Evoker - dropped Guven, Mondrivun and Ramaliny after gating and bringing a train

        at which point we summoned corpses and camped for the night.

        I went back to look through my play times, I have probable spent (2+2+2+4+6+2+3+2+2+2+3+3+5+4+3+2+2+2+4+4+2) 61 hours "camping" for meat This is not total kill time, but time to get to the zone if I had camped in PoK after summoning corpses, buff time (self buffed, not PoK buff begging), rez effect time, etc.

        The web site indicates the meat does drop in lavaspinners (and the instances), and people have posted that they have looted the meat... I guess the RNG hates me enough that I won't be getting it any time soon.

        Mon
        Bristlebane
        Mondrivun
        Enchanter of 7th Cavalry
        Bristlebane

        Being level 80 with a gazillion AAs, Group Leadership Abilities, and Raid Leadership abilities is not THE ultimate part of the game. It may be YOUR ultimate part of the game, but it is not MY ultimate part.

        Comment


        • #5
          Be glad Ngreth took the meat out of the new SoF train rations recipie hehe

          Comment


          • #6
            wow i junked like 4 stacks of the stuff just the other day.
            j/k sorry had to. TBH sounds like an awful bad luck. I farmed that zone constantly for a very long time, still go back for fun, the stuff drops saw a fair amount, then again I was there farming scales which didn't exactly have a great drop rate themselves.

            Comment


            • #7
              Have had a buyer up (on and off) for a few weeks offering 4k per Nest Drake Meat..... and slaughtered in Lavaspinners a lot, but no luck.

              The real killer is someone in the Baz is selling a Nest Drake Soup for 4plat. I talked to that person but they didnt have any actual unused meat.

              This problem is going to get worse and worse as less and less people use that expansion.
              Pootle Pennypincher
              Short in the eyes of some...
              Tall in the hearts of many!

              Comment


              • #8
                I don't remember Drake Meat being such a problem when i did baking trophy.

                But Nightmare Sap is killing me(

                Comment

                Working...
                X