So I am a proud member of Infinit, which is the core of the public raiding system on E'ci-Tunare. We're an unusual public group in that we're basically the secod best raid force on our server, and we actually beat the leading guild to be the first to clear Frostcrypt.
We took 8 of our best players -- the best warrior, cleric, wizard, necro, ranger, plus another cleric, ranger(me), and a beastlord. We had 2 out of group for back-up heals and dps. Everyone has mostly TSS raid gear, with a smattering of Demi/Dk. We set up camp in the blimp in the Fortress and began slaughtering gnomes at 9:45am. Non-stop.
At 4:15pm, we had 32 "a reavers" killed. I went afk for the last 8 mobs, so I don't know how long that took.
I've gotten it done now, and my guildmates helped me, so I can consider it a day's work, but it feels like if I were to have brought a single group of non-TSS-raid-geared people, there is no way that could be done in a week. The single group would have trouble keeping up with the spawn rate (like 12.5 minutes, but PLEASE don't increase that, b/c you need fast spawns to have a chance of popping reavers). If the "a reaver" spawned as commonly as "a trooper" it would be much more manageable -- we must have killed 200 troopers to get 40 reavers.
Anyway, I think as it stands, the quest is only going to be doable by Raiders, or possibly if an entire non-raiding guild were to work on it as a team, for their main tradeskillers' benefit. That might be by design, but if so, I'd recommend advertising it as such -- have the quest giver recommend "If you are not a raider, you may want to bring several groups of friends"
Thanks, as always, for the excellent attention to tradeskills in this forum. Just my 2 cents and take it for what it's worth (i.e. 2 cents!!!)
Andy/Guiscard
We took 8 of our best players -- the best warrior, cleric, wizard, necro, ranger, plus another cleric, ranger(me), and a beastlord. We had 2 out of group for back-up heals and dps. Everyone has mostly TSS raid gear, with a smattering of Demi/Dk. We set up camp in the blimp in the Fortress and began slaughtering gnomes at 9:45am. Non-stop.
At 4:15pm, we had 32 "a reavers" killed. I went afk for the last 8 mobs, so I don't know how long that took.
I've gotten it done now, and my guildmates helped me, so I can consider it a day's work, but it feels like if I were to have brought a single group of non-TSS-raid-geared people, there is no way that could be done in a week. The single group would have trouble keeping up with the spawn rate (like 12.5 minutes, but PLEASE don't increase that, b/c you need fast spawns to have a chance of popping reavers). If the "a reaver" spawned as commonly as "a trooper" it would be much more manageable -- we must have killed 200 troopers to get 40 reavers.
Anyway, I think as it stands, the quest is only going to be doable by Raiders, or possibly if an entire non-raiding guild were to work on it as a team, for their main tradeskillers' benefit. That might be by design, but if so, I'd recommend advertising it as such -- have the quest giver recommend "If you are not a raider, you may want to bring several groups of friends"
Thanks, as always, for the excellent attention to tradeskills in this forum. Just my 2 cents and take it for what it's worth (i.e. 2 cents!!!)
Andy/Guiscard



Ngreth Thergn
)
Comment