Combine Success Rates for Planar Armour?

[Hzark]

What are the combine success rates for planar tailored armour for a 250 tailor?

[Hzark]

20% ? :shock:

Is that on elemental armour?

What about PoN/BoT stuff?

[Lizzzard]

I'm 3 / 5 success on Earth Leather Armor, 8 / 12 Earth / Air Silk Armor, most of that at 239+GM needle, the last 3 or 4 combines at 241.

[data9724]

Thats on the elemental armor.
Havent bothered with any BoT armor (SO not worth it imo), and only did a few robe of haunted dream combines for money, so cant say for sure what the success rate is.
But elemental tailoring is around 20% success rate, but been a little better lately, maybe up to 25% or so. Was major failure rounds the first few times i did it.

[Damion]

Im 7/9 on PoN robes. 1/2 on PoS legs.

250 Tailor + Geerlock

[adetia]

2 for 6 on fire robes
1 for 2 on earth sleeves

250 tailor + trophy

[munwin]

im about 30 of 60-70 on various pieces of Elemental armour, and 2 for 2 on Robes of haunting dreams. Lately ive been noticing a higher fail rate on brewing my curing agents (252 Brewer) failing 3 of the last 7.


Munwin

[saum]

im 1/2 on earth silk armor and
im 1/2 on fire robes

All attempts at 250 with GM needle

[Forthofer]

I succeed about two-thirds of the time on elemental leathers and silks, with skill 221-223 plus 15%.

[Daethaan]

At 250 tailoring:
1/1 Firestrand Legs
0/2 Firestrand Arms
2/2 Robe of Ancient Earth
2/2 Earthweave Legs
1/4 Earthweave Arms
0/1 Stonehide Legs

2/2 Storm Rider Tunic
2/3 Storm Rider Legs
1/1 Storm Rider Arms
1/1 Storm Rider Gloves
1/1 Storm Rider Cap
(didn't keep track of earlier nightmare/storm stuff)


EDIT: Did some more combines.

[Kasanya]

At 250 skill, I've been running a success rate of 100% on PoN silk robes and about 50% on PoS leathers, and I've made a ton of both. Am also 1 / 1 on PoEarth silk robe, but I'm guessing that was a lot of luck there. =)

[adetia]

3 for 7 on fire robes
0 for 1 on earth robe
1 for 2 on earth sleeves
0 for 1 on earth legs
0 for 6 on fire legs

250 tailor + trophy

[xonbink]

4 outta 5 attempts on Storm Rider BP and leggings -

250 skill + needle -


xonbink

[Dazzler Desiderare]

To me it seems the lower tier stuff, PON, POS has a fairly high success rate. Once I got access to the elementals that sure changed for me atleast. Namely PoE Silk Legs, went 2 for 2 , then the "streak" hit. Failed the next 9 attempts. **** near went through the monitor and wrecked the loom!!! :x BTW...I am 247 skill with a 15% mod so its not like my skill wasnt on par...just the RNG was having a spot of fun with me.

After I calmed down for a week , I went back to the wrecthed loom and made PoE Silk Sleeves the first shot. Now im not afraid anymore!

[Jeddia]

The success rate on the high end planar stuff is rather disconcerting. I presume it's the same for smiths and potters. But considering the amount of work it takes to get to 250 Tailoring - I think we deserve a little better than 15-20% success.

The majority of the high end tailors are non-elemental flagged folks (people who don't belong to an elemental-capable guild) and have spent a lot of time on tradeskills. These folks (like myself) have to buy a lot of the components from other players. The success rate on the stuff ensures we take huge losses to get some nice stuff made. Breaking even I could understand - but taking a 70kpp beating is ridiculous when you stop and think "This is it. My skill doesn't go any higher than this...".

And like a previous poster stated, the lower tier PoP stuff is almost unfailing it seems. I'm 12 for 12 on Haunted Dream robes....but I still fail 3 of 5 Arctic Wyvern Masks.. lol err.

Someone up in SOE Codeland should have a look at some of this stuff maybe...