Success rates on blue diamond armor

[Flabbo McFattyfatfat]

While its not statistically significant, wanted to share last night's run (my first) on blue diamond armor.

Skill 229 (+5%)
255str/255 wis
Straight out of the mean streets of ogguk!

Blackended Darkscale Bracer 1/3
Blackened Darkscale Vambraces 1/1 (woohoo!)
Blackened Darkscale Pauldron 1/8 (doh!)
Blackened Darkscale Boots (0/2)

Failed on 3 of the sheets of ogguk adamantate. But hey, its only trivial by a billion points, so I should expect that huh? >

so 3/15, or roughly 20%. Any idea what a smith of this skill level (roughly 240) runs normally?

Also, I have always had horrible luck on pauldrons. Back from my banded days, and especially noticable in fine steel. Normally dont make em. I think its some kind of curse from my own shoulders for leaving a bloodstained mantle on em for 47 levels...

[Balthozzar]

success rates

I kept track of my combines when I first started BD cultural at 230 +5% skill, up until I hit 234 skill and took a bit of a break. I made a total of 91 combines, for 39 successes. (42%) Seems like you just had a bad streak there with shoulders. I was 3 for 6 during that time on those.

[ratamah]

My succes rate with 250 is about 40%

[Jessamyn Sunweaver]

Ugh...

I really wish I had kept track of all the combines I had did. It would of totaled well over 500 though I'm sure.

However, in my recent runs I've had the following results.

Edit: This is with a character with 250 raw skill and the Grandmasters Smithy Hammer, max INT, etc.

Bad day

3/7 Heraldic Bracers (various imbues)
0/4 Heraldic Boots

That is about the time I gave up and let my hammer melt in the forge.

On a more recent set...

2/3 on Fierce Heraldic Bracers
1/2 on Fierce Heraldic Visor
1/1 on Fierce Heraldic Gorget
1/1 on Fierce Heraldic BP
1/2 on Fierce Heraldic Pauldrons
0/2 on Fierce Heraldic Vambraces
1/1 on Unimbued Heraldic Bracer

I was quite pleased after that run to say the least

[wold2]

success rate on BD cultural

This stuff is tough. I'd say I'm about 40% overall on at least 100 combines.
Last session: 0/3 on artficer's bracers. Session before that : 0/3 on artificer's bracers, 1/2 artificers greeves, 1/1 artificer's arms, 1/2 Helanic tundra helm, 1/2 helanic tundra belt, 1/2 helanic neck, 1/1 helanic face mask., or something like that. The 1 ring combines can be very tough. For some reason I've always done worse on the shaman armor than on the warrior armor. I'm 250 skill + geerlok.
They claim that you lose 1% success rate per skill level . So if I'm at 252 (cap) and do 40%, you'd average 28% success at effective 240.
At 240 you might want to power level with sickles because I'll bet you'd break even or even make money and you can get to 250 if you do a couple hundred sickles.
I can't stand doing sickles anymore but I went from 242 to 250 on em.

[Eleena Transient]

At 252, I'm currently 34 for 78 on full mithril armors (43.5%)

[Arghargh]

248 + Grandmaster Smith's Trophy
2/7 on bracers

Arghargh Grumble, Darkblood
57 Ogre Shaman of Rallos Zek
Alchemy – 160
Baking – 200
Brewing - 200
Fishing - 200
Fletching – 200
Jewelcraft –200
Potting - 200
Grandmaster Smith - 250
Tailoring – 159

[tokkus]

Has anyone noticed different success rates between a lowly bracer and a BP ( and everything in between)? I'm short on tempers, and need to decide on an order in which to smith..

[Abazagaroth]

Over about 900 cultural combines now I'm just over 40% success rate. It was closer to 44%, but my last hundred combines or so were so poor my overall success rate dropped a couple of % points.

RNG has been terrible lately, very streaky, even compared to before.

[wold2]

bd success

last run :
4/4 artificers bracers
0/3 artificers bracers
2/2 artificers bracers
1/4 artificers belt (success on last one)
250 skill plus geerlok
Very streaky but not a bad session

[Elmarr Armoursmythe]

Last Runs Data

My last 5 runs, all done at 250 skill with Geerlok and Trophy equipped:

Run 1 - 2 for 9:
1/3 Fetid Heraldic (Bertoxxulus) Breastplate
1/3 Fetid Heraldic (Bertoxxulus) Boots
0/3 Fetid Heraldic (Bertoxxulus) Bracers
For a guildie - not such a good run

Run 2 - 2 for 2:
2/2 Fine Heraldic (unimbued) Bracers
For a guildie - a good run

Run 3 - 3 for 3
1/1 Fierce Heraldic (Rallos Zek) BP
1/1 Fierce Heraldic (Rallos Zek) Greaves
1/1 Fierce Heraldic (Rallos Zek) Boots
(And a very happy guildie - good because I failed 2 BDs in the kiln/brew barrel for him just a few days before)

Run 4- 1 for 2
1/2 Luminant (Mith Marr) Heraldic BP
To replace my own, which I sold

Run 5 - 3 for 3:
1/1 Fierce Heraldic (Rallos Zek) BP
1/1 Fierce Heraldic (Rallos Zek) Greaves
1/1 Fierce Heraldic (Rallos Zek) Boots
And a very happy Troll cusomer

Among those I have had an inordinate amount of failures on trivial combines on BDs (failures in kiln, brew barrel and forge), but the final combines have generally been good. Success rate looks to be about 50/50 (though I've been real lucky in the last series of runs, as you can see).
Regards,

[Flabbo McFattyfatfat]

Last nights results

Fulvous Darkscale Greaves 1/1

Fulvous Darksplint Bracer 1/1
Fulvous Darksplint Tunic 1/2

Crimson Darksplint Bracer 1/1

Crimson Darkscale Greaves 1/1
Crimson Darkscalre Bracer 1/1
Crimson Darkscale Boots 1/2

I was speechless, until

Crimson Darkscale Pauldron 0/3

YAR! Sorry Froanz we work on yer shoulders later bud

Again, my pauldron curse kicks in. Thinking of subcontracting these things lol!

[Elmarr Armoursmythe]

Latest BD Smithing Data

Latest runs from this weekend, making Fierce Heraldic (all done at 250 skill with Geelok and Trophy):

1/1 BP
1/3 Greaves
2/4 Bracer
1/1 Boots
1/2 Vambraces
1/1 Helm
1/2 Gaunts
1/1 Visor
1/3 Gorget
(10 for 18 overall, used 31 rings, lost 4 BDs on trivial combines - 1 in Kiln, 1 in Barrel, 2 making rings - 35 BDs total)

1/1 Greaves
1/1 Helm
1/1 Bracer
1/1 Pauldron
1/1 BP
(5 for 5 overall, used 11 rings)

0/2 Greaves (combines attempted for a guildmember who provided supplies - lost one BD in barrel)

Overall a very nice 15 for 25. It was a good weekend.
Regards,