Smithing Skill Up Data

[Baltazor]

Making a push to skill up my smithing. My plan is to make 400 combines of Mistletoe Sickles. I have made all the Sacred Dust of Tunare and Mistletoe Tempers to begin and stockpiled CE. I will do them in batches of up to 10 (depending on subcombine success). My Int is 415, Dex 450, all other stats at 365 cap Smithing Skill to start was 259 and I am using a Hammer of the Ironfrost (15% Smithing modifier). I also have Smithing AA Mastery 3 + Salvage 3.

Summary
For those of you who want to "cut to the chase", success rate on subcombines (Trivials ran 181 to 183) was:

Sickle Blades: 143/147 (97.3%)
Hilts: 136/139 (97.8%)
Pommels: 142/148 (95.9%)

Mistletoe Sickles: 130/143 (90.1%)

Total of 6 skill ups for 143 attemps or on average 1 in 24 attempts.

Some Salvage statistics: (recovery/failure data)

Sickle Blades: 3/4 (75%)
Blades: 2/3 (66.7%)
Hilts 6/6 (100.0%)
(average all three above it equals 84.6%)

Mistletoe Sickles: 11/13 (84.6%)

First Run:
Sickle Blades 9/10 (Salvaged 2 components on 1 failure)
Hilts 10/10
Pommels 10/10
Mistletoe Sickles 7S, F, S (260) - 8/9 (Salvaged 1 component on 1 failure)

Second Run:
Sickle Blades 9/10 (Salvaged 2 components on 1 failure)
Hilts 9/9
Pommels 7/8 (Salvaged 2 components on 1 failure)
Mistletoe Sickles - 9/9

Third Run:
Sickle Blades 10/10
Hilts 9/9
Pommels 10/10
Mistletoe Sickles 4S, S (261), F, 4S - 9/10

Fourth Run:
Sickle Blades 9/9
Hilts 10/10
Pommels 10/10
Mistletoe Sickles 4S, F (262), 8/10 alvaged 1 component on 1st failure & 3 components on 2nd failure) 3S - 8/10

Fifth Run:
Sickle Blades 10/10
Hilts 8/8
Pommels 9/10 (Salvaged 2 component on failure)
Mistletoe Sickles F, 3S, F, 5S - 8/10 (Salvaged 1 component on 1st & 2nd failure)

Sixth Run:
Sickle Blades 9/9
Hilts 10/10
Pommels 9/10 (Salvaged 1 component on failure)
Mistletoe Sickles 9/9

Seventh Run:
Sickle Blades 9/9
Hilts 10/10
Pommels 10/10
Mistletoe Sickles 10/10

Eighth Run:
Sickle Blades 9/10
Hilts 10/10
Pommels 9/10 (Salvaged 2 components on failure)
Mistletoe Sickles 9/9

Ninth Run:
Sickle Blades 10/10
Hilts 8/8
Pommels 10/10
Mistletoe Sickles 6S, F, 3S - 9/10

Tenth Run:
Sickle Blades 10/10
Hilts 10/10
Pommels 10/10
Mistletoe Sickles - 9S, S (263) 10/10

Eleventh Run:
Sickle Blades 10/10
Hilts 9/9
Pommels 10/10
Mistletoe Sickles F, 4S, S (264), 3S - 9/10 (Salvaged 1 component on failure)

Twelveth Run:
Sickle Blades 10/10
Hilts 9/10 (Salvaged 1 component on failure)
Pommels 10/10
Mistletoe Sickles 9/9

Thirteenth Run:
Sickle Blades 10/10
Hilts 10/10
Pommels 8/10 (Salvaged 3 component on 1st & 1 component on 2nd failure)
Mistletoe Sickles 3F, 6S - 6/9 (Salvaged 1 component on 1st, 2nd, 3rd failure)

Fourteenth Run:
Sickle Blades 10/10
Hilts 5/6 (Salvaged 1 component on failure)
Pommels 10/10
Mistletoe Sickles 5S, F, 4S - 9/9 (Salvaged 1 component on failure)

Fifteenth Run:
Sickle Blades 9/10 (Salvaged 1 component on failure)
Hilts 9/10
Pommels 10/10
Mistletoe Sickles 5S, F (265) 4S 8/9 (Salvaged 1 component on failure)

Stay tuned for more run information.

Baltazor Goldsinger
Fennin Ro Enchanter

[Baltazor Goldsinger]

Some more Run data... same stats as above. Starting skill level was 266.

Run 16:
Sickle Blades 10/10
Hilts 10/10
Pommels 9/9
Mistletoe Sickles 9/10

Run 17:
Sickle Blades 10/10
Hilts 10/10
Pommels 9/10 (Salvaged 1 component on 1 failure)
Mistletoe Sickles 9/10

Run 18:
Sickle Blades 9/9
Hilts 9/9
Pommels 10/10
Mistletoe Sickles 9/10

Run 19:
Sickle Blades 9/10 (Salvaged 2 component on 1 failure)
Hilts 10/10
Pommels 10/10
Mistletoe Sickles 5S, 267, 3S - 9/10

Run 20:
Sickle Blades 10/10
Hilts 9/9
Pommels 9/9
Mistletoe Sickles 10/10

Run 21:
Sickle Blades 10/10
Hilts 10/10
Pommels 10/10
Mistletoe Sickles 10/10

Run 22:
Sickle Blades 10/10
Hilts 10/10
Pommels 10/10
Mistletoe Sickles 10/10

Run 23:
Sickle Blades 10/10
Hilts 10/10
Pommels 10/10
Mistletoe Sickles F, 4S, F, 5S 9/11 (Salvaged 2 component each on 2 failures)

Run 24:
Sickle Blades 9/10 (Salvaged 2 component on 1 failure)
Hilts 9/9
Pommels 10/10
Mistletoe Sickles 9/9

Run 25:
Sickle Blades 10/10
Hilts 9/10 (Salvaged 1 component on 1 failure)
Pommels 9/9
Mistletoe Sickles 9/9

Run 26:
Sickle Blades 10/10
Hilts 9/9
Pommels 10/10
Mistletoe Sickles 9/10

Run 27:
Sickle Blades 10/10
Hilts 10/10
Pommels 10/10
Mistletoe Sickles 10/10

Run 28:
Sickle Blades 9/10
Hilts 10/10
Pommels 9/10 (Salvaged 2 component on 1 failure)
Mistletoe Sickles 8/9

Run 29:
Sickle Blades 10/10
Hilts 9/9
Pommels 10/10
Mistletoe Sickles 10/10

Run 30:
Sickle Blades 9/10 (Salvaged 1 component on 1 failure)
Hilts 10/10
Pommels 9/9
Mistletoe Sickles 9/9

Run 31:
Sickle Blades 10/10
Hilts 10/10
Pommels 10/10
Mistletoe Sickles 10/10

Run 32:
Sickle Blades 10/10
Hilts 9/10
Pommels 10/10
Mistletoe Sickles 7S, F, 2S 9/10

Run 33:
Sickle Blades 10/10
Hilts 10/10
Pommels 10/10
Mistletoe Sickles 10/10

Run 34:
Sickle Blades 10/10
Hilts 10/10
Pommels 10/10
Mistletoe Sickles F, 2S, 269, 270, 6S - 9/10

Run 35:
Sickle Blades 9/9
Hilts 10/10
Pommels 10/10
Mistletoe Sickles 271, F, 4S, 272, 3S - 9/10

Run 36:
Sickle Blades 8/10 (Salvaged 1 comp on 1 failure and 2 on 1 failures)
Hilts 10/10
Pommels 10/10
Mistletoe Sickles 8/8

Run 37:
Sickle Blades 9/9
Hilts 10/10
Pommels 10/10
Mistletoe Sickles 273, F, 8S - 9/10

Run 38:
Sickle Blades 10/10
Hilts 9/10 (Salvaged 1 comp on 1 failure)
Pommels 10/10
Mistletoe Sickles 8/9

Run 39:
Sickle Blades 10/10
Hilts 9/10
Pommels 9/9
Mistletoe Sickles 3S, 274, 8/9 (Salvaged 1 comp on 1 failure)

Run 40:
Sickle Blades 10/10
Hilts 10/10
Pommels 10/10
Mistletoe Sickles 10/10

Run 41:
Sickle Blades 10/10 (Salvaged 4 comps on 1 failure
Hilts 10/10
Pommels 9/10 (Salvaged 2 comps on 1 failure
Mistletoe Sickles 1S, F, S, 275, 4S, 276, 8/10

Run 42:
Sickle Blades 9/10
Hilts 9/9Pommels 10/10
Mistletoe Sickles 10/10

That's all for Mistletoe sickles ~ doesn't seem to be that much interest in them anyways!