Lightningbane? what have I got wrong?

[Sunshadow]

Tried this 67 Wiz spell last night.

Vellum
Luclin Ink Additive
Quill of the arcanist
Ink of Pain
Arcane thickener

Did not combine? Anyone help.

Sun

[Queletan]

Try adding an Ink of Druzil Ro, the spell shows a resistance modifier for magic on Lucy, that should account for it.

Q

[Qaladar Bragollach]

Try adding an Ink of Druzzil Ro.

This is an inconsistency. Firebane requires an extra ink for the lure check. Icebane doesn't.

[eq_anki]

Ahhh and i was just about to ask since i tried the same recipe this morning

Luclin Ink Additive
Ink of Pain
Arcane thickener
Quill of the arcanist
Vellum

Will try the extra ink tonight, thank you!

[Sunshadow]

Tried it. Still did not combine.

[Queletan]

Well, according to logic that should be in but sometimes things get overlooked.. I'll try to fiddle with it some tomorrow if I can remember. Might try trying the two inks in various quantities (0-2/0-2), but I can't think of any other suggestions off hand.

Q

[Ngreth Thergn]

The bane spells have an ink in them for the resist ajustment.

[Queletan]

Hmm.. Well I tried ~20 different combines (different #s of inks of pain and druzzil ro, even tried rainbows and marr, and swapped the additive for Nameless just for fun), no go...

In theory it should be:

Vellum (67 spell)
Quill of the Arcanist (Wizard spell)
Luclin's Ink Additive (Lightning damage spell)
Arcane Thickener (Direct Damage spell)
Ink of Pain (Spell that causes damage)
Ink of Druzzil Ro (Spell has a resist modifier to magic)

But thats a no go. I'm at a loss unless someone else has other suggestions.

Q

[Sunshadow]

I'll try adding an Ink of E'ci just in case the missing Icebane Ink found it's way accidently into the Lightningbane recipe.

Sun

[Qaladar Bragollach]

Ink of Terris Thule? It would be wrong but thats what I would try next.

[Qaladar Bragollach]

The bane spells have an ink in them for the resist ajustment.

Firebane does, Icebane doesn't, Lightningbane matches neiter of the 2.

Need a little help here.

[eq_anki]

Tried about the same as Queletan, no luck :s
Played with additive and multiple ink... druzzil and pain is all it should be, imo

[Ngreth Thergn]

Bah. there is a bug in the recipe.

I have the AOE thickener (Al'Kabor) instead of the proper Arcane.

I will change it, but in the short term. use that thickener. Otherwise Queletan is correct, and it is what it will be when it is patched (Sorry I did not notice this yesterday, though it still may have been too late for the patch)

[Sunshadow]

That's OK mate, thanks for posting and letting us know what the problem was.

Sun

[eq_anki]

confirming it worked with Al'Kabor Thickener

thanks for the help everyone!