Tradeskill Trophies succes rates?

[Khoren Stonefall]

Smithing: 1/1
Jewelling: 1/1
Baking: 1/3
Brewing: 1/2
Fletching: 1/1
Pottery: 1/1
Tailoring: 1/1

So, 7 for 10 altogether. I was 10/11 on making emblems (I failed a firing).

I suspect I was quite lucky. I still guess these are 40% success items like blue diamond armor, etc.

[Mardark]

1/2 at 218 Smithing +5%

[Kingbobb]

Made my smithing trophy on the first try, had skill around 220, with gearlock. Was 1 for 1 on all steps.

[bigbadda]

Attempt at a fletching trophy!

level 62 dwarven warrior (so you know my int/wis sucks) with a base skill of 202 fletching. I'm looking to make my trophy and was wandering what i could do that would help? Obviously I'm going to borrow some int/wis gear from friends and make sure to have a C3 before I try my combines. Is there any +fletching items out there aside from the geerlock?

[Perseverence Rewarded]

I failed 1 try for my GM fletchers knife at 202 skill. Didn't try again. Scaredy cat

Succeeded on first try at 220 skill yesterday :shock:

Great stats and I love the carry-all.

[Taqwus]

I am 1 for 1 on my drinking cork
tried it at 250 + Geerlock

[chubbyone]

I am one of those poor shmucks lol 5 tries 0 trophies skill 250, used geerok as well. Time to go get some more money to waste

[Taushar]

Pottery Trophy, 1 for 1 at skill of 230 or so with Geerlock and Wisdom at 250.

Brewing Trophy, 1 for 3 at skill of 250 with Geerlock and Wisdom at 280 to 285.

I got lucky with pottery one. Brewing seems to be about average with 1 for 3 or so.

Taushar

[Chenier]

Tailoring needle:
Success on seal, fail on combine at 228 + geerlok, wis 280ish
Success on seal, success on combine at 232 + geerlok, wis 280ish

/happy dance =)

[Delfontes]

GM Corker

242 + Geerlok Failure

2 months later

246 + Geerlok, Success

1 for 2

[Perseverence Rewarded]

I successfully combined my Grandmaster Smith's Hammer on the first try this morning at 214 smithing skill. All sub-combines succeeded also.

I am now 2 for 3 on Trophies. Fletcher's Knife and Smith's Hammer

[Raiyaeq]

Smith hammer:
fail - 221 skill + geerlok 255 int
success - 240 + geerlok 255 int

Pottery trophy:
fail - 228 + geerlok 355 wis
success - 236 + geerlok 355 wis

Baking spoon:
success 250 + geerlok 355 wis

Tailoring needle:
failed seal twice in kiln, once in wheel with 250 + trophy (ouch)
success 239 + geerlok 355 wis

[Modred]

Jewelcraft 1 / 3 - Failed first attempt on final combine, failed 2nd attempt on firing of seal.
Baking 1 / 1

[Tythis]

/sigh

4 failures of 4 attempts at Tailoring trophy with 250 tailoring + 5% geerlock with 355 int and 302 dex (if it even matters). I did succeed first time on the jewlerycraft trophy however. I'm not sure what I consider worse luck... 4 failed tailoring trophies or the batch of 110 sickle combines with only 1 skill up last night. Oh well, back to the salt mines.

[Sethlic]

Made 250 baking a few days ago and then tried my trophy. Got it on the first Try I'm so happy. I was worried I could only find one black saphire.