Guild Hall lack of skillup after SOF release

[Yank]

Ok. I hate to sound like a newb here... i rely on this board for accurate info.
I hope i am just the victum of the RNG (random number generator).

I've done 1000 (yes a full 1k) pottery combines in my guild hall. im at 299 pottery. Since release. NO skill up. /cry. (unfired star ruby encrusted stein)
I then did 100 smithing combines. NO skill UP. (sunshard ore - chain wrists)

I moved to POK. did six combines and got 2 skill up in fletching...

My Trophies gained % points in hall and pok.


/frustration

[Flehmen]

Hmmm, without more reports I'd say it's just bad luck..

More info on the skill level of the fletching and smithing might help. None of what you've mentioned is really out of bounds.

[Chaparrell]

Similar experience

I had similar experience. I did about 55 combines making Fine Silk Wristband templates on the loom in my guild hall. No skill ups. I moved to PoK and got 3 or 4 skill ups on the remaining 70 or so combines. I did, however, switch from wristbands to gloves. I was worried that the wristband pattern was bugged; I didn't consider that the GH Loom might be unique in any way.

[Maevenniia]

Not sure if this applies to skill ups, but Ngreth previously posted that evolving trophies in the Guild Hall is "unreliable"...quoted below:

Actually what it is is "unreliable" in the guild hall. Your millage will vary

I find that from time to time, instances do not get "script" data. And when this happens, trophy's will fail to work in the instance. Guild halls are instances. Probably most of the time you will be fine. But if you really find a problem... move out of the instance into a live zone and you should have better luck.

But almost ALL of the reports that I have been able to track down as anywhere near valid on the trophy not working... has been in guild hall, and when it is that, it is because guild hall was missing some data... NOT because the trophy itself was broken.

I have continued to pursue the problem of data sometiems not being complete in the guild hall.

[Roanne]

The simple way to test this is to take a low skill character into the guild hall and do some simple recipes and see if he or she gets skillups. Its probably just coincidence, but other strange bugs have appeared in the game from seemingly unrelated problems.

[sivas]

Just the other day I did a couple spell research combines in the guild hall, level 70 combines which usually increase the trophy by a couple percent each, and they didn't change it at all. I haven' noticed that problem in the past but perhaps I wasn't paying enough attention and it sounds intermittent. I hope that's fixed, but until then I guess I'll stay out of the GH when doing combines. That's annoying since in the past I've always done combines for guild mates in the GH since it was the most convenient spot to meet.

Sivas

[Roanne]

The issue with trophies not evolving in the GH is a known bug related to the script responsible for trophy evolution sometimes not loading in instances.

Dont evolve your trophy in the GH.