Top 10 List

[Myrron]

While that would be pretty cool to have, let's keep this thread focused on tradeskill items, please. Non-tradeskill related suggestions could probably be posted in their appropriate locations on the official Sony forums (http://eqforums.station.sony.com/eq), or /feedbacked.

--Myrron Lifewarder

[Maevenniia]

Tracking is not a tradeskill. This request should be made on your class Top 10 list (ranger? Druid?)

[Bellawood]

17) Ghoul of Takish-Iz broken, very frustrating!


Killed it some 30 times on Venril Sathir along with a friend who killed it for me about 10 times. Never dropped the anchor. This is the lamest camp/droprate in the entire game, and the terrible thing is that you can fail the combine AND the item is no drop. PLEASE PLEASE make this better.

Sincerely,
Bellawood Soulsaver
Firiona Vie

[Tillinghast]

D'oh!

Um, well, tracking is good for finding TS related mobs, yeah, that's it!


Tillinghast
Vendor Mule
Horse's Backside

[Celestya]

Here's my top 5 for the next time the list is updated.

1) Expanding Jewelcrafting Mastery to other classes - with the addition of OoW augs, it's not really fair to keep this enchanter only. They already have enough of a monopoly on tradeskills, with being the only ones able to make SOOO many of the required items for nearly every skill, NOT just Jewelcrafting.

2) Rotating stock on vendors
Tanker said it wouldn't be too hard to code vendors to erase the oldest item sold to them, rather than the newest.
Your humble correspondent does not have an update on this specific issue.

3) Bag tokens:
3A) Showing bag stats when inspecting the tokens.
3B) Additional Tokens for bags.
Easy enough to do, especially with the compiled list. This will be one of the few items most likely to get done first, since it's not going to take a *ton* of time to do. *especially ice cream churns!!! I love ice cream, but I don't want to sacrifice a 10-slot bag for one*

4) Nitram Anizok's plight
Tinkerers are concerned about the ability to get to Nitram in Innovation, as he is the only vendor for certain non-stacking tinkering supplies.

5) Tradeskill Super-trophies
"The discussion of a super-trophy you can only obtain at 1750 skill or after having all seven normal trophies is still a hot topic for discussion here.
This is likely to be done, but not sure when -- Possibly a future expansion feature." What do you know! One is coming up in a few short weeks. *puts on her puppy face*

[Maevenniia]

-More GoD recipes, for things that have little to no use yet, like Taelosian Wheat and Taelosian refined Clay (als, the Sludge and the Muramite Biles)

- Researchers don't have a trophy yet!! Even fishermen get a nice doodad (that not only summons poles, but BEER too!) I want a quest to convert my Advanced research book into a collapsible item. (I'd ask for a neat doodad that also lets us summon alcohol, but alcohol + magic users = dangerous combination! Could we summon magic cookies instead? )

-minor but desirable: new bag designs and/or ability to DYE bags. I'm bored of the same old graphics, plus it would help to manage my bank & inventory if I had more variety in the looks. If I could dye them, that would be great...brown is so dated..... I loved the new bag look for the bag that people received as a /claim item (for LoY, I think, Satchel of Abu-Kar) but no other bags have since been given that graphic

[Aryse Andenter]

Oooh ooh ooh, dyed bags please!!! That is a brilliant wonderful idea!!

Being able to 'personalize' the way they look, not to mention being able to tell at a glance which contains my research/quest/vendor/tradeskilling supplies etc. would be wonderful.

[Nolrog]

Some very good ideas.

I wasn't planning on changing the list (except for adding a nice post that was written by someone (forgot who, sorry) on the Artisan's Way. However, if we feel that one of these is more important to use than what's already there, then we can add one, as long as we remove one as well.

[Celestya]

Just thought you'd be updating the list, taking into account what has been changed recently (the spiderling silk drop rate has already been looked into and addressed, as has the Poison Mastery AA I believe. (the usual no bugs found for that one)).
I believe someone brought up the dying of bags a while back and was told it wasn't able to be done. hmmm. Maybe there are new changes now that would allow for it though. It would be wonderful. I loved that ability on The Realm.

[Nolrog]

Just thought you'd be updating the list, taking into account what has been changed recently (the spiderling silk drop rate has already been looked into and addressed, as has the Poison Mastery AA I believe. (the usual no bugs found for that one)).

I updated the list as soon as we found out these were addressed. You can find the current list here. Be sure to scroll down to the last post, which has the most updated version of the list.

[Pulvani]

This is probably something that's not important enough to warrant being on the top 10 list (yes, I read through it first, hehe), but perhaps it's an easy fix.

Is there any way to make the ice cream recipes require some kind of ice *other than* ice of velious? Ice of velious is too rare and can't really be farmed, per se....the salts that were formerly required could at least be farmed (although it's great that was changed ) Maybe we could use the chunk of ice from the golras in TD? Just a thought Ice cream is fun and I enjoyed the challenge of acquiring items to make the churn, but now I'd like to use it sorta often Thanks for the consideration.

[Celestya]

*huggles* Thanks Nolrog. I was going by your post here, not the one on the eqlive boards. My mistake.
*bounces* I can't wait to see if any of the 'big' changes get added to DoN to make it appealing to those of us that don't raid, but play solely for our love of tradeskills.

[Elyssanda]

Substitute for #5 on the list...

Nolrog? Since #5 says
5) Tradeskill Super-trophies

This isn't something that I'm inclined to do quite yet, though it is something that we might do in the future, perhaps as part of an Aid Grimmel / Shawl style quest.

Could we substitue the dye-ing of bags for it? Everyone is always looking for ways to get through their banks/inventory faster and this would really help.

[Mannwin Woobie]

Without stirring up any Enchanter-bashing, was there ever a REASON given as to why they are not considering opening up JCM to the rest of the classes?

I'm sorry, this thing just sticks in my throat. To take a skill that is not class-restricted and restrict the Mastery of it to a single class is outrageous. OK, just admit it was a mistake and fix it. You know you can do it. You don't even have to admit the mistake...we'll take a quiet behind-the-scenes fix

Roll it out with the new expansion. Yeah. That's the ticket......

[Celestya]

I believe SOE claimed it was because Jewelcraft Mastery was a class-defining AA for enchanters.
Most of those I've spoken to, seem to think the only reason it wasn't opened up is because SOE doesn't want to come up with a replacement AA for enchanters. *shrugs*
Until they realize a non-restricted tradeskill should have a non-restricted mastery, I'll sit in my little corner praying to Tunare and failing outrageously on the new augs.