Skill 168, Minotaur Hero's Brew or Faydwer shaker then Brew

[sir0die]

My skill is currently 168, should i make Minotaur Hero's Brew or Faydwer shaker then Brew.

Faydwer shaker combine elven wine, gnomish spirits, dwarven ale, mead (failure yields cask + 4 bottles, success yields 1 shaker and 4 bottles) cask yeilds 1, triv @ 188

elven wine $0.015
gnomish spirits $0.068
dwarven ale $0.068
mead $0.052
cask $0.031
-----------------------------------
total $0.234

plus the sell back of 4 bottles, my server is down, so i can't put an exact value on it.



Minotaur Hero's Brew combine 3 malt, yeast, 2 flask water, 2 short beer (success yields 1 brew and 2 empty bottles, failure yields 1 cask and 2 empty bottles) cask, yeilds 1, triv @ 248

malt $0.016
malt $0.016
malt $0.016
yeast $0.016
flask water $0.010
flask water $0.010
short beer $0.016
short beer $0.016
cask $0.031
-----------------------------------
total $0.157

plus sell back of 2 bottles.


the trade off for doing the shakers first would be more success to sell back, but if i have to gather items in multiple zones, that would suck.

I know that the brew can be done in Sh without having to leave (have to run all over).

the worse part is they both require casks, so pack space is somewhat limited. The brew uses 8 items in it(other than casks, wher the shaker only uses 4. I would have to make many more trips to vendor to make the brew, just to buy casks.

there also that rumor that the further away from triv, the less chance of a skill up. So would that make a major difference? or am i at the mercy of the RNG?

[Candien]

At 202 skill in Brewing atm, went from 151-202 On Mino Hero brewm easy to make... Planning to do it to 248 and then Kaladim cons to 250

You will fail alot at first, but doesnt really matter, a stack of Minos sells for around 2pp, so not even worth selling

*EDIT* A stack off bottles sell for 1gp, so i just drop em on the ground, not worth selling

[Unix]

I used freeport for my Mino Brews.. Then again, this was right after luclin came out. God, I don't even remember what I did to get to 200, but I started mino brew at 200, took me 29 hours on/off of combining to get my 250. (Mino to 248, and 3 tainted ava ales to 250.. this was before constitutionals/etc)

[ChaseFV]

First one, then the other.

I would recommend doing the Shakers first, as you can find all the components in buildings next door to one another in East Freeport, or in a single building in Highpass. The nine-item nightmare that is MHB's is to be avoided as much as possible. It's cheap, it's easy, but it's hard on the wrists...

Good luck
Chase
Half-Elven Ranger of Tunare
45 seasons wandering the wood in defense of Her creatures
High Council Member and Guild Master Brewer of the House of Carnage
Firiona Vie

Brewing 250
Fletching 200
Baking 195
Pottery 189
Fishing 180
Tailoring 152
Smithing 115

I agree with dodging it Sordie...

Go to EFP, and make shakers, all really close together, gets you quickly to 188.

You'll have plenty of time to enjoy the mino brew days, hehe.

For mino brew, I'd buy enough for 80 combines...

12 Malts,
4 yeast
8 short beer
8 water

32 inventory slots

Then you can buy unstackable casks... I would empty 5 10 slot backpacks, (helped being a tailor, 2 of the backpacks I'd sell after brewing, and remake next time I needed to brew... can't wait for GM trophy) and only be able to buy 18 casks, then go back and forth... so you may want a barrel very close to a cask seller.

If you're stopping at 200, you should be able to do it in about 400 combines from 188.

Good luck .

[Eumerin]

Which factions are the vendors in EFP on, and how close do the guards get to the relevant merchants? I've helped take Lucan down twice, so this is an important issue for me...
I thought I'd found the sweet spot when I noticed the Fungus Grove supplies in the listing on the main site, but unfortunately, casks aren't available in that zone.

Merchants have their own faction, I thought it was simply merchants of FP, but I would have to check.

I didn't see any guards when doing my shakers, but I was mainly inside, and wouldn't have taken any notice of the ones patrolling outside.

A few people have suggested HHP, a building there seems to have everything you need to make them and few people are KoS to those merchants.

Got bored, checked Illia's Everquest bestiary for factions in EFP...

Interestingly enough, most of the merchants are listed as monster on their site, with no factions listed.

Guess they got lazy.

The ones that show as 'merchant' are listed under:

Carson McCabe
Coalition of Trade Folk
Coalition of Tradefolk Underground
Corrupt Qeynos Guards
Freeport Militia

I Think that means they wont trade with you if you've been killing guards, but seeing as how poorly the site did this zone... it may just be completely off.

[Eumerin]

Both Coalition of Tradesfolk Illegal and Freeport Militia get bottomed out fairly quickly with Lucan kills. I'm fairly certain that the head bartender at the Seafarer's Roost is on Illegal, but unfortunately, I'm not certain about the rest.
Not sure right now if I'll look into EFP, or if I'll find another location to handle it all.

[tatanka7th]

Do the shakers first. Items that have a close trivial versus your current skill will give quicker skillups, and fail less so you will have more to sell back to the vendors.

Tat

[Calabar]

I would suggest checking out the brewing merchant in Halas. I seem to remember reading a very long thread about which zone it was best to brew in, in which someone posted that you could do all your brewing of Minotaur Hero's Brew in one room. I read this after reaching 199 brewing with Minotaur Brew in Kaladim. So I can’t speak from first hand knowledge. But it’s still worth checking out. Now that my baking is over 200, I may go Halas and see about getting that last point.

[Omardeth]

if ya have the money make grobb liquidised meat . you can sell in bazaar and the stuff is all vendor bought in sh . and it will go to 216 i think . cost more to make but u can make more in bazaar selling them instead of back to vendors .

[sir0die]

hmmmm, Halas you say, my home town, and with the PoK book nearby........... Any clue as to which room it might be? I spend alot of time in Halas. Afterall I am a barbarian shaman.

[Valya Wanderfoot]

Faydwar shakers can be made easily in EFP. That is the best place IMO.
You buy the imported wines at the Import shop, then go next store to Trader's Holiday to buy the mead and the casks. There's a brew barrel right in Trader's Holiday, so even if you only have room for a few casks, it's easy to step back to the merchant.

The mercants in question are NOT KOS if you have killed Lucan. Unfortunately, to use the area in peace I first had to kill about 6 guards... moving from Trader's Holiday to the Import store I got agroed. I'm a paladin tho and don't have an easy source of unlimited invis.

[Cathoir Ghall]

If you are interested in another option ...

Go to Shadeweavers Thicket. There is a ground spawn there called Payala Fruit. Combine the fruit and a flask of water in a brew barrel. Will take you to trivial of 187.
It sells back well to vendors and sometimes to those who are making Faithstones/Spiritstones.
The only thing you've invested is a little time to pick up the fruit and the cost of water.

Then you can brew up some Minotaur Hero's brew.