Brodder's Revenge revisted...

[Brodder FoamyMugs]

Okies me initial recipe had whiskey in it...
Yall can figure out how whiskey's made...
Basically water + malt + grain/corn is fermented den mixed wif peat moss and aged/distilled into oak/elm barrels.

Two recently found items make me tink dat they (SOE) is on track with my original recipe. We(and I) may have missed the boat here.
Older whiskey's don't work so maybe my underfoot whiskey would work...
Think that was underfoot brown + something distilled into a cask.
that might be seperable into shots or bottles.
What's this item...it's hinted above...

Peat Moss, fished in PoNightmare, Tranquility

PEAT MOSS is also a forage from DEEPEST GUK

Now you just need to find a whiskey recipe that's on list but not sold anywhere and tradeskill useable.

heh let's call this Brodder's Blend for testing sake. (sake not Saki/sake`)

Once the whiskey is found and brewed/distilled/aged we can focus again on main recipe.

Good luck folks...

[Rewde]

Oh sure... Give us something ELSE to work on....


And so it continues. Perhaps, someday, we will finally have this done.

[Barli]

I know, lets just give Brodder a Regurgatonic and make him spit up the hidden recipes! If'n he won't talk then feed him a Tainted Avalanche Ale. (j/k)

I just hope these recipes result in a drink that many players will ask for and want to buy - and hopefully something that has a trivial >250 so that we GM's can be in demand.

Whiskey! Aye - a warriors drink!

Underfoot whiskey eh? Something to use those left over shrooms from the dwarf farm on.

[Naeadiene Needsamap]

Does anyone buy the paper and pen sets? While browsing the sony site I saw a blurb about the newest book. Apparently it's about Luclin.

Maiden of Shadows

Not sure if I linked that correctly. I remember reading about in game quests that came from these books. I haven't ever seen the books myself. But if someone has a chance to look, maybe there are clues for Lewena's Secret.

[Kandrak]

Hmmmm. Whiskey = Fire water?

[dahna]

Peat moss could not be fished in PoT, will try PoN later.

DNC list so far :
Any combo of
Peat Moss/Water/Malt/Short Beer/Shoot glass/Cask/Bottle

[nyetro]

hmm.. maybe it could be

Curled Whisker Whiskey?

Saw this on Lucy's database but not on EQtraders or Allakhazam's website. I remember something being mentioned about a certain dwarf curling his whiskers. Anyways i believe that possibly its the Underfoot brown and something else, im gonna brew some today and see if its tradeskill flagged. Who knows...

[Gaeolas]

Since whiskey uses a grain of some kind, might make sense to try some barley or rice.

I'll give it a try if I log on this evening and no one seems to have beat me to it.

[Vuron808]

Very frustrating.

Anyways i believe that possibly its the Underfoot brown and something else, im gonna brew some today and see if its tradeskill flagged.

It's not tradeskill flagged.

This leads me to think the raw ingredients for UB are used.

The biggest problem here is the hints are IMO incredibly misleading. It is difficult to fill in the blanks when you don't even know how many and where they are.

Older whiskey's don't work so maybe my underfoot whiskey would work...

I take this to be the goal.. to make underfoot whiskey?

Think that was underfoot brown + something distilled into a cask.

OK. So UB is not flagged which is why I thought the ingredients of UB were used here instead. Anyway, the right side of this equation is goofy.

"something distilled into a cask." could mean (UB + something) distilled into a cask... meaning a cask is the container type used in the combine of UB + something.

OR it could mean UB + (something distilled into a cask) meaning that a subcombined something is needed.

that might be seperable into shots or bottles.

Seems obfuscation to me or at least leaning towards the 2nd option above UB + (something distilled into a cask) + (shot or bottle).

What's this item...it's hinted above...

Uh.. what? So peat moss is in. Except I also read this to mean that peat moss is the 'something' in the first option: UB + something == UB + peat moss.

Now you just need to find a whiskey recipe that's on list but not sold anywhere and tradeskill useable.

Huh? I don't get this part at all. It sounds easy but I couldn't figure any way to jibe this with the rest of the hints other than it seems a known recipe is one of the ingredients.

DNC:
1. UB ingredients + peat moss
2. #1 + various other combined alc drinks (vodka etc.)

Varied both #1 and #2 for different container types. I'll probably do a more exhaustive try on #2 but it seems futile given my confusion.

[Vuron808]

Assumptions for this set of attempts:
Combine involves underfoot brown (even though it isn't tradeskill flagged) + a known brew (that is tradeskill flagged, but isn't vendor sold).

For each test I varied the number of underfoot browns and the number of 'other brews' both up to two each. I also tried each combination with and without peat moss, and also by itself or with a shot glass, cask, or bottle.

Tried:
Tumpy Tonic
Vodka
+ several others (don't have my notes handy). Basically I worked off the brewed alc list here trying brews that weren't vendor or sold and not using the beers/wines.

[Quichon]

How about using the underfoot MUSHROOMS instead of the bew. We know they are tradeskill flagged, and making a whisky out of underfoot mushrooms will make an underfoot whisky.

Mebbe mushroom + malt + water + Peat moss?

I can't seem to get any Peat Moss, so I can't try it out, but given the standard formula for whisky is water/malt/grain, if you switch out the grain for a mushroom that'll be something a dwarf would do.

[YurienStonebow]

ok refresh my memory. if somethign isn't marked tradeskill useable are we stilla ble to combine it?

[Renjah]

Cobalt Drake hides DONT have a tradeskill flag yet are used in tradeskills. The absence of a flag does not rule out any item.

[Lixivia]

Two recently found items make me tink dat they (SOE) is on track with my original recipe. We(and I) may have missed the boat here

does this mean you do not actually know what the recipe is, or if it works, or that you just have an idea of what it was supposed to be like?

[Vuron808]

Originally posted by YurienStonebow
ok refresh my memory. if somethign isn't marked tradeskill useable are we stilla ble to combine it?

I got hung up on this initially too until a friend with much more tradeskill experience corrected me. My first batch of tries I use the ingredients for UB because it wasn't flagged. Second I used the UB.