researching Concussive Blast rk. II

[Roanne]

Concussive Blast Rk. II

Wizard level 71

Spell Type: Detrimental
Skill: Alteration
Target Type: Single
Duration: Instant
Resist: Magic (0)

1: Decrease Hate by 5000

Concussive Blast Recourse
1: Chance to create Lifeshard(35)
2: Chance to create Lifeshard(35)
3: Chance to create Lifeshard(15)

NOTE: This is actually a random short term buff that lowers the hate caused by whichever of the elemental types you get the process for.

"Shocks the mind of your target, causing them to forget some of the harm you have done to them. This spell has a high chance to bestow a Concussive effect to your spellcasting that will greatly decrease the hate generated by your next three ice, fire, or magic spells."

[Roanne]

I think the recipe should be:

Rough Paper
Quill of the Arcanist
Debilitating Thickener
Luclin's Ink Additive
Ink of Innoruuk

The first three items seem pretty strait forward. I tried swapping Ink Additive of the Nameless because the effect works even if it's resisted (but not the recourse in my limited experience). I also tried (x2), (x3), (x4) Ink of Innoruuk as well as (x1) and (x2) Ink of Innoruuk + Ink of Eci, Ink of Ro, and Ink of Druzzil Ro. I tried every combine with and without Chronal Resonance Dust. I also tried all these variations with Arcane Thickener.

I don't know what else to try here. Any thoughts?