Trivial For Artisan's Seal Changed?

[teeth444]

at http://www.eqtraders.com/secrets/recipes_trophies.htm it says making the seal is trivial <= 107. However, with 128 and having succesfully made the non-fired seal it has failed in the KILN for me 4 times.

Anyone know why?

Is this a bug and petitionable?

Can one fail in a Kiln?

[Ilona]

Anything can fail in the kiln.
Failing in the kiln 4 times is EXTREMELY unlucky :(

[Bartox]

made 2 seals
failed 1 in kiln

pottery 243

go figure.

[teeth444]

Anything can Fail in the kiln?

so pottery skill is not <= Kiln?

Kiln is on it's own skill level?

It appears to be broken and I encourage all to send feedback to VI.

[Ghanima]

don't understand your reasoning. Of course anything can fail in the kiln. Any tradeskill combine for any skill has a chance of failing (unless of course it's one of those few "no fail" combines). How does this indicate that something is broken?

[Cigarskunk]

However, with 128 and having succesfully made the non-fired seal it has failed in the KILN for me 4 times.

Anyone know why?

Just bad luck - the kiln seems to know when you're firing something extremely expensive or rare and as such it saves up to give you the 5% failure then.

I've only had the plat to take a shot at one GM trophy and the kiln ate the final combine on me too with a 175 pottery skill.

All said, you are just having an EXTREMELY bad run of luck. If you feel that you are bugged, try making some junk and firing it - bowls, cups, whatever - if all of those kiln attempts fail as well, then you've got yourself a real bug on your hands, if they're mostly ok, then it's bad luck.